Human Systems and Behavior

Economics Greed: The Dark Side of Human Motivation ← Series Home Key Takeaways The Velocity of Paper: The intense speculative frenzy in the Dutch Tulipmania was primarily a phenomenon of a futures market, where bulbs were sold entirely **"on paper"** from mid-September onward, accelerating price swings twentyfold in a single month. Macro Greed, Government Scale: The Mississippi and South Sea Bubbles were not simply crowd folly, but **grandiose macroeconomic schemes**—large-scale **government debt-for-equity swaps**—backed by the entire apparatus of the governments of England and France. The Plausible Theory: Speculators gather around **convincing theories**, not each other. Law's scheme was initially a **plausible theory** for revitalizing the French economy through financial innovation, lending credibility to the resulting price surge. The Destruction of Honor: The critical system flaw in all early manias was the dependence on **honor and credit** to uphold paper promises. The collapse of the tulip trade manifested as a wholesale **breaking of promises** (or "bad faith") by buyers who refused to receive and pay for worthless goods. The most shocking element of the Dutch tulip speculation—the rapid, astonishing rise in prices—was fundamentally driven by a simple, yet powerful, mechanism: the futures market. While the high prices of rare bulbs were a “standard feature of markets in newly developed varieties,” the notorious “mania” centered on the common bulbs was an extremely short-lived phenomenon: a frenzy lasting only one month between January 2 and February 5, 1637. ...

Economics Greed: The Dark Side of Human Motivation ← Series Home Key Takeaways The Crisis of Reality: The astonishing valuation of tulip bulbs disrupted all previous economic and cultural certainties, creating fundamental confusion over **what was valuable, worthy, and real**. The Rise of the 'Goldist': The mania was fundamentally driven by **avarice**, leading critics to label speculators not as flower enthusiasts but as **"goldists"** who sought "odious" gain over honest, traditional toil. Social Inversion: Pamphleteers condemned the sudden acquisition of quick wealth, which blurred class lines and led to the terrifying spectacle of artisans and "foul rabble" becoming "schijn-heeren," or **"seeming-gentlemen,"** thereby dominating society and reversing the proper order of things. Betrayal of Trust: The collapse did little financial damage initially; the true crisis was a **social and cultural shock** resulting from the wholesale breaking of promises and the resulting destruction of the **honor and credit** necessary for society to function. The legendary prices paid for tulip bulbs, such as the Viceroy (reputedly worth a long list of actual commodities), immediately established the speculative phenomenon as a moral problem, not just a financial one. The value system of the Dutch Golden Age was suddenly thrown into disarray: what was valuable, what was worthy, and what was real. Critics were incredulous, unable to conceive why a tulip—a transient flower—should be valued so highly. The flower was not noticeably better than any other and was considerably less tangibly valuable than standard commodities or treasures. ...

Economics Greed: The Dark Side of Human Motivation ← Series Home Key Takeaways The Absurdity of Value: The high price of tulips, such as the Viceroy, was so astonishing that contemporaries created lists of goods (wheat, oxen, wine) of equivalent value, putting all existing economic certainties into disarray. The Legend is Propaganda: The enduring narrative of pervasive stupidity and madness is drawn almost entirely from satirical pamphlets and moralistic propaganda published immediately after the crash, rather than objective financial records. A "Sickness of the Head": Contemporaries, including the priest Jodocus Cats, described the mania as a "sickness" or "craziness" driven not by love of flowers, but by the "odious" pursuit of private, quick profit over honest toil. The Futures Mechanism: The market allowed prices to surge twentyfold in a single month because the entire trade was essentially a futures market conducted entirely "on paper," delaying delivery and payment until the summer. Whenever financial instability flares up, particularly concerning highly speculative assets, the Dutch Tulipmania of the 17th century is invoked almost ritually as a warning against speculative excess. The image that has become legendary a story of huge fortunes won and lost is focused on the most improbable of all financial objects: the tulip bulb. The enduring power of this historical pattern lies in the sheer, bewildering absurdity of the object being valued. ...

Key Takeaways Market Randomness: Stock prices are unpredictable, as Louis Bachelier demonstrated in 1900, with human herd behavior complicating pure mathematics. Expert Failure: Professional forecasters perform no better than random chance, leading to the rise of passive index investing. M&M Propositions: A company's value is independent of its financing structure or dividend policy in a rational market. Excess Volatility: Stock prices fluctuate far more than underlying dividends, revealing irrational market psychology. Redefining Risk: Eugene Fama dismantled his own CAPM model, showing that market risk includes size and value factors beyond beta. --- Introduction It’s a common feeling: financial markets seem impossibly complex, a domain of arcane mathematics and high-speed computers. Or, they’re brutally simple, driven by the raw emotions of greed and fear. For over a century, some of the most brilliant minds in economics and mathematics have tried to discover the hidden “rules” that govern this global game of risk and reward. What they found is often far more surprising and counter-intuitive than we might assume. ...

References Allstate. (2022). Drivewise: How it works. https://www.allstate.com/drive-wise/how-it-works.aspx American Farm Bureau Federation. (2023, January 9). AFBF, John Deere sign right to repair memorandum of understanding [Press release]. https://www.fb.org/news/afbf-john-deere-sign-right-to-repair-memorandum-of-understanding BMW Group. (2022). BMW “Functions on Demand” now available in South Korea [Press release]. https://www.press.bmwgroup.com/global/article/detail/T0398118EN/bmw-%E2%80%9Cfunctions-on-demand%E2%80%9D-now-available-in-south-korea Cambridge Mobile Telematics. (2023). The state of driving 2023. https://www.cmtelematics.com/state-of-driving-report/ Consumer Federation of America. (2023). Usage-based auto insurance: A consumer perspective. https://consumerfed.org/reports/usage-based-auto-insurance-a-consumer-perspective/ Consumer Reports. (2022). What does your car know about you? We studied the privacy policies of 15 car brands. https://www.consumerreports.org/cars/car-safety/what-does-your-car-know-about-you-a1034782797/ ...

References Adensamer, A., Gsenger, R., & Klausner, L. (2021). “Computer says no”: Algorithmic decision support and organisational responsibility. Journal of Responsible Technology, 7, 100014. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jrt.2021.100014 Bauer, W., Hämmerle, M., Schlund, S., & Vocke, C. (2019). Designing AI-supported human-machine interaction. International Journal of Human-Computer Studies, 131, 25-39. Bernabei, M., & Costantino, F. (2024). The role of automation in operator performance degradation: A systematic review. Safety Science, 170, 106329. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssci.2023.106329 Bloch, K. (2016). Incident investigation. In Rethinking Bhopal (pp. 45-67). Elsevier. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-803778-2.00003-5 ...

References Anderson, C. (2009). Free: The future of a radical price. Bregman, R. (2017). Utopia for realists. Caballero-Anthony, M., Cook, A., & Chen, C. (2021). Knowledge management and humanitarian organisations in the Asia-Pacific: Practices, challenges, and future pathways. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 53. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijdrr.2020.102007. Chisengantambu-Winters, C., Robinson, G., & Evans, N. (2020). Developing a decision-making dependency (DMD) model for nurse managers. Heliyon, 6. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2019.e03128. Church, P., Cavanagh, A., Lee, S., & Shah, V. (2019). Academic challenges for the preterm infant: Parent and educators’ perspectives. Early Human Development, 128. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.earlhumdev.2018.09.016. ...